CIA of Operation Management

Well since I have your attention and you may be wondering what CIA has to do with operations. CIA was the termed coined by one of my clients as “Central Item Allocation” during an enterprise transformational project. Large manufacturing companies face three prominent challenges that are rated very highly in customer surveys. The top three challenges are resistance due to cultural challenges, managing proliferation of IT systems and coping with Mergers and Acquisitions.

This article discusses the third challenge of merger and acquisition, particularly with respect to operational efficiency. In the last 10 years there has been a proliferation of companies going global. The reasons are varied and range from 1) access to low cost resources, 2) access to new markets and 3) a way to hedge the market by diversifying. However these acquisitions have created a monster of a problem to the COO and the CIO. Millions of dollars are being spent on building a common standard business processes across cross cultural and national boundaries. One of the key decisions that come up during due diligence efforts is whether to build a single instance or a distributed set of systems across the enterprise. Single instance is beneficial from a TCO (Total Cost of Ownership) point of view, but causes two problems. It takes the ability from the individual sites to manage their manufacturing. It takes the individuality away from the plants which have unique characteristics and strengths. The best people to manage the operation are usually the people at the plant who breathe and live the production on a daily basis. With the single standard across the enterprise, they have to comply with the corporate standards. The second problem is a situation where the company may decide to divest a manufacturing unit; it becomes a highly complex process to separate the IT infrastructure.

Integration of the acquisition is a nightmare and has to be managed diligently. The challenge faced by the COO is to determine the best way to utilize the distributed capacity “effectively” to serve the variable market demand. CIA was coined to develop a common order taking process that would consider the demand characteristics and allocate the orders intelligently to the individual manufacturing sites.

Some of the key factors that were considered during the design phase were 1) How to create a level capacity loading, 2) How to promise profitability, 3) How to promise based on logistics costs, 4) How to accommodate customer preferences and 5) Can the small lot orders be aggregated in bigger lots before promising. Overall the CIA function can become very complex if all the decisions have to be considered during order promising. The challenges are to accommodate all the logic within a short interval of time to ensure that customers and sales representatives do not have to wait for an inordinate amount of time to get a promise date. To make this happen, some basic fundamentals have to be in place, to develop this solution in a multi plant environment. This cannot be done without the standardization of products and processes – thus the single instance of an enterprise application plays a critical part.

A comprehensive successful implementation of CIA will help in better utilization of the capacity across multiple plants, balanced production and load leveling, reduction in delays and shortened cycle times, aggregation of small lot orders and improved customer service.